Read @ Joe’s

Title: The Lonely Crowd (2026) Director: David St. Clair Writer: David St. Clair Studio: Desario Productions IMDb Plot: Peter and Ashley’s online date escalates into a heated battle of the sexes. When Ashley storms out, Peter finds her being harassed and intervenes, unwittingly getting involved with corrupt cops, kidnapping, and stolen money. Joe Says: A low-budget indie that does its best to look and feel like a million bucks. But, a little more crazy could have turned this lonely crowd into a loud one.

The crime genre is as old and long as the law itself. History, romance, comedy, heist, even horror can all take up residence in the genre like safety deposit boxes in a bank vault. In The Lonely Crowd, filmmaker David St. Clair uses crime fiction as his getaway car, but what he’s really interested in is something more intimate: isolation, dating fatigue, and two people who have built enough emotional walls to qualify for their own zoning permits.

St. Clair uses quick dialogue and dry humor to explore those themes while keeping the crime deadly serious. But the film feels trapped between the spotlight of these two worlds. Like many young indie filmmakers eager to show off their stylistic range, St. Clair opts for the safe middle. The Lonely Crowd could have benefited from choosing a side: floor the gas on the comedy or plunge headfirst into a dark, pulpy underworld.

The Lonely Crowd features Peter (Adam Wesley), a former ballplayer who is striking out as a civilian, meets Ashley (Taylor Anne Danehower), a woman trying to prove she can rebound from a criminally bad ex. 

Their first date delivers the expected barbs, awkward smiles, and flickers of chemistry. Ashley’s bright eyes and Peter’s boyish smile make a significant run at their erected defenses. Alas, bad news hits as Ashley’s ex, Jake (Giancarlo Carmona, who is a tad too boy-band-ish to be truly menacing), breaks out of the pokey and sends his right-hand man Phil (Jon Oshei) after Ashley and the money she scammed from her man. 

Suddenly Peter’s romantic evening turns into a bad episode of the Dating Game.

St. Clair shifts into noir territory from there, dropping Peter into a world of corrupt cops, stolen drug money, and inconvenient timing. Peter attempts to survive the night. And maybe even score a second date.

The film has shades of Martin McDonagh in its collision of romance, dark humor, and criminality, but St. Clair keeps his foot firmly on the brake. The Lonely Crowd is clearly flirting with a blend of romance and chaos, yet it never takes the plunge. A little more pulp. A little more danger. A little more Blood Simple and a little less Hallmark Channel could have given the story  considerably more bite.

What he has created is entertaining, enjoyable, and even a little different. Wesley and Danehower have an easy, believable chemistry, and their characters feel like actual people rather than rom-com placeholders. St. Clair and cinematographer Garrett Stotko also find striking beauty in the quieter corners of the story, capturing everyday streets, passing strangers, and those lonely stretches of city life.

And that’s where The Lonely Crowd ultimately works best. The crime is the hook, but the challenge of relationships is the story. 

The Lonely Crowd is a low-budget indie that does its best to look and feel like a million bucks. Wesley and Danehower prove they can carry a picture, while St. Clair shows he has the eye and the ambition to go further. A little more crazy could have turned this lonely crowd into a loud one.

---

Don’t feel left out. The Lonely Crowd is available on Amazon Prime Video.